How to Choose the Right Herding Dog Breed for Your Livestock



My name is Tyler, the proud owner and experienced publisher of Paws & Purrrs. I've always had a soft spot for our furry friends, and over the years, I've been blessed to share my life with many pets. This love for animals, coupled with my passion for sharing knowledge, led me to create this blog.

Table of Contents

Are you a farmer or rancher looking to add a herding dog to your team? Choosing the right breed for your livestock can make a huge difference in the success of your operation. With so many different herding breeds out there, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. But don’t worry, with a little research and consideration, you can find the perfect match for your specific needs.

First and foremost, it’s important to consider the size and behavior of your livestock. Some breeds are better suited for herding cattle, while others excel with sheep, goats, or even poultry. Additionally, the temperament of your livestock should be taken into account.

Are they skittish and easily spooked, or calm and docile? These factors will all play a role in determining which herding breed will be the best fit for your operation. So, before making any decisions, take the time to thoroughly evaluate your livestock and their needs.

Consider the Size and Behavior of Your Livestock

Understanding the temperament and physical characteristics of your animals is crucial when selecting a herding pup. Your livestock may be timid or aggressive, and you need to choose a dog breed that can handle their behavior appropriately.

If your livestock is timid, a dog that is too aggressive may cause more harm than good. Similarly, if your livestock is aggressive, a timid dog may not be able to control them effectively.

When choosing a herding dog breed, you must consider the size and behavior of your livestock. For instance, if you own large livestock such as cattle or horses, you need a dog that can handle their size and strength. On the other hand, if you own smaller livestock such as sheep or goats, you need a dog that is gentle and nimble.

Understanding the behavior and needs of your livestock is the first step in selecting the right herding dog breed.

Evaluate the Terrain of Your Property

When evaluating the terrain of your property, it’s important to consider whether you have open fields or hilly terrain. If you have open fields, a herding dog breed with a lot of speed and agility may be best suited for your needs.

However, if you have hilly terrain, a breed with endurance and strength may be more appropriate. Additionally, weather conditions should also be taken into account, as certain breeds may be better equipped to handle extreme temperatures or heavy rain.

Open Fields vs. Hilly Terrain

If you’re looking for a herding dog breed that can handle both open fields and hilly terrain, there are a few options to consider. Border Collies, Australian Shepherds, and Kelpies are all known for their versatility and ability to work in a variety of terrains.

When evaluating the terrain of your property, it’s important to consider the physical abilities of your herding dog and choose a breed that can keep up with the demands of the land. Training techniques and necessary equipment will also play a crucial role in your dog’s ability to handle the terrain.

For example, teaching your dog to navigate steep hills or rocky terrain may require specialized training techniques and equipment such as a harness or boots. It’s important to work with a professional dog trainer who has experience working with herding dogs and can help you choose the right training techniques and equipment for your specific breed and terrain.

With the right breed, training, and equipment, your herding dog will be able to navigate open fields and hilly terrain with ease, making them an invaluable asset to your farm or ranch.

Consider Weather Conditions

Before hitting the fields with your furry companion, it’s important to take into account the ever-changing weather conditions, much like a sailor navigating through choppy waters. Adapting to climate is crucial when choosing the right herding dog breed for your livestock.

Some breeds are better suited for colder climates, while others thrive in hotter weather. For instance, Border Collies, Australian Cattle Dogs, and German Shepherds are great options for colder climates due to their thick coats. On the other hand, Australian Shepherds and Catahoula Leopard Dogs are better suited for warmer weather.

Training in weather is another factor to consider when selecting a herding dog breed. It’s important to gradually introduce your dog to different weather conditions, such as rain, snow, and wind, during training sessions. This will help them become more comfortable and confident in any weather situation.

Additionally, providing your dog with proper shelter and hydration during extreme weather conditions is crucial for their health and safety. With patience and responsible training, you and your herding dog can overcome any weather obstacle and work together to ensure the safety and well-being of your livestock.

Assess the Temperament and Training Needs of the Herding Dog Breeds

When considering which herding dog breed to choose for your livestock, it’s important to assess their temperament and training needs.

Border Collies are highly intelligent and energetic, requiring a lot of mental and physical stimulation.

Australian Shepherds are also highly intelligent and energetic, but tend to have a more laid-back personality.

German Shepherds are loyal and protective, but can be more aggressive and require firm training.

Corgis are smaller in size, but still have a strong herding instinct and require adequate exercise and training.

Taking the time to evaluate these factors will help you choose the best herding dog breed for your specific needs.

Border Collies

You can’t go wrong with a Border Collie for your herding needs – they’re intelligent, agile, and have a natural instinct to control and move livestock. These dogs are known for their work ethic and willingness to please their owners, making them a popular choice among farmers and ranchers.

However, it’s important to note that Border Collies require a lot of mental and physical stimulation, as well as consistent training to reach their full potential. Here are some important things to keep in mind when considering a Border Collie for your herding needs:

– Training techniques: Border Collies are highly trainable, but they respond best to positive reinforcement methods such as rewards and praise. Harsh training techniques can cause fear and anxiety in these sensitive dogs, leading to behavior problems.

– Exercise requirements: Border Collies are high-energy dogs that require a lot of exercise to stay healthy and happy. They need plenty of space to run and play, as well as mental stimulation to keep their minds engaged.

– Health concerns: Border Collies can be prone to certain health issues such as hip dysplasia, epilepsy, and eye problems. It’s important to choose a reputable breeder and schedule regular check-ups with your veterinarian to ensure your dog stays healthy.

Socialization: Border Collies can be shy and reserved around strangers, so it’s important to socialize them from a young age. Exposing them to new people, places, and experiences can help prevent fear and aggression.

– Grooming: Border Collies have a thick double coat that requires regular brushing to prevent matting and tangling. They also shed heavily twice a year, so be prepared for some extra clean-up during those times.

Australian Shepherds

If you’re looking for a versatile and highly trainable dog that can keep up with your active lifestyle, the Australian Shepherd may just be the perfect addition to your family. This breed is known for their intelligence, agility, and loyalty, making them a great choice for any herding or farm work.

They’re also great family pets, as they’re affectionate and enjoy spending time with their human companions. One of the pros of owning an Australian Shepherd is their ability to learn quickly and follow commands with ease. They’re highly trainable and excel in obedience, agility, and herding trials.

However, their intelligence can also be a con, as they require a lot of mental stimulation and exercise to prevent boredom and destructive behavior. When training your Australian Shepherd, it’s important to be patient and consistent, using positive reinforcement techniques to encourage good behavior.

German Shepherds

Now that you’ve learned about Australian Shepherds as a herding dog breed, let’s move on to another popular choice: German Shepherds. These dogs are highly intelligent and trainable, making them a great option for herding livestock. However, before deciding on a German Shepherd as your herding dog, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons.

One advantage of German Shepherds is their natural instinct to protect their family and territory. This protective nature can be beneficial when working with livestock, as they can help keep predators at bay.

Additionally, German Shepherds are known for their agility and endurance, which makes them well-suited for herding tasks. However, it’s important to note that German Shepherds can have a strong prey drive, which may lead them to chase and potentially harm smaller animals. Proper training and socialization can help mitigate this behavior.

When it comes to training, German Shepherds are eager to please and highly trainable, making them a great choice for novice herding dog owners. Consider enrolling in obedience classes or seeking the guidance of a professional trainer to get the most out of your German Shepherd’s herding abilities.


Get ready to fall in love with the adorable and spirited corgi, the next dog breed we’ll explore as a potential herding companion.

Known for their short legs and fluffy butts, corgis are not just cute, they are also great herders. However, it’s important to note that corgis have a unique temperament that may require a specific approach when it comes to training.

Corgis are intelligent and eager to learn, but they can also be stubborn and independent. To effectively train a corgi as a herding dog, it’s essential to establish a clear hierarchy and consistently enforce rules and boundaries.

Positive reinforcement techniques, such as treats and praise, are also effective in motivating corgis to learn new skills and behaviors. With patience and persistence, a corgi can become a reliable and enthusiastic herding companion.

Find the Perfect Match

Discovering the ideal herding companion is like finding a needle in a haystack, but don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Before you begin your search, it’s important to consider the following points:

– Your Livestock: Different breeds have different herding styles, and some may not be suitable for your livestock. For instance, a breed that is too aggressive may not be the best choice for small or timid animals.

– Your Property: The size and terrain of your property can also play a role in choosing the right breed. A dog that is too small may not be able to handle large pastures, while a breed that is too large may struggle in tight spaces.

– Your Lifestyle: Owning a herding dog requires a significant commitment of time and energy. You’ll need to be willing to provide regular exercise and training to keep your dog happy and healthy.

– Training Techniques: Different breeds respond better to different training techniques, so it’s important to research the best methods for your chosen breed.

– Breed-Specific Health Concerns: Like all breeds, herding dogs can be prone to certain health problems. Make sure you research any potential health concerns before making a final decision.

By taking the time to consider these factors, you’ll be better equipped to find the perfect match for your livestock and lifestyle. Remember, choosing a herding dog is a big decision, but with the right research and preparation, it can be a rewarding and fulfilling experience for both you and your new companion.


Congratulations on taking the first step towards finding the perfect herding dog for your livestock! By considering the size and behavior of your animals, evaluating the terrain of your property, and assessing the temperament and training needs of different breeds, you’re well on your way to making an informed decision.

Remember, choosing the right herding dog isn’t just about finding an animal that can perform the task at hand, but also about finding a companion that will work together with you and your livestock. It takes patience and responsibility to train a herding dog, but the bond you’ll form with your furry friend will be well worth the effort.

As you embark on this journey, keep in mind that the perfect match may not come immediately. You may need to try out different breeds, or even different individual dogs, before finding the one that truly fits your needs. But don’t give up hope – with persistence and knowledge, you’ll find the right herding dog for your livestock, and together, you’ll form an unbreakable bond that will last a lifetime.

More Posts: